For some reason, war is often associated with the concept of heroism. Writers sometimes associate it with the layout pursued by noble career and intellectual professionals, following strategies that may even include the concepts of protection, liberation or empowerment. Too many for the novel. On the other hand, anyone who is eager to get close to the realities of war should be breathless, ready for the worst, and then read Paul Preston's Spanish massacre.
Of course, this war is a Spanish civil war. In this case, the reason for the lofty is that military coups cancel the democratically elected government, and specialized professionals tend to adopt a way of agreeing and stopping the body. Let's take a look at the practice of using castor oil for the beaten, and then marching through the streets as they walk uncontrollably while walking. By the way, these people are often shot.
Of course, there are atrocities on both sides, and anyone who continues to argue against these old battles by abandoning these or those that may be reasonable arguments may be accused of being the same ruthless as the original criminal. Of course, the only important thing is evidence. Paul Preston's authoritative description of this period is complete and has good references to support his position. The assertion that is crucial to his position is that most war crimes are insurgents, nationalists, who have won history in history, while leaders have ruled Spain for forty years. If you are a pro-fascist, a Nazi sympathizer, or an avid rightist, you should avoid this book before that, because you won't like it.
But then Paul Preston's Spanish massacre was not a history of war. It more describes the consequences of war, revenge, revenge, and the idea of victory. This book is almost a catalogue of abuse, campaigns, battles, and towns. The author compares the numbers reported by both parties with the identified and identifiable victims. He has compiled data from various sources, official records, relatives, newspaper reports, eyewitness accounts, and materials recently discovered by the survey. Multiple sources are always necessary, because many are rendered as novels because of embroidery, so Paul Preston will never see things as faces. Through, he cross-references his source, scrutinizes his assertions and conclusions, and always makes mistakes in terms of lack of speech.
He believes that combatants who died in custody. He listed prisons and prison camps for prisoners. He described the walk ' the detainees were forced to take action and strolled to Campo, which proved to be a one-way entry into the shallow tomb, some of which were not yet positioned, let alone unearthed.
Paul Preston pays special attention to the fate of victims, nuns and other religious believers who will not be victims of extrajudicial or retaliatory killings. At the time, the fate of these people provided the majority of anti-communist propaganda for nationalists, and this propaganda affected the external acceptance of the victory of the rebels. In the Spanish massacre, Paul Preston reviewed evidence related to many atrocities, including the murder of religious personnel. The pictures he reconstructed show that both sides have killed murders and nuns, but they have consistently found that nationalist claims have been exaggerated, and that a large number of Republican victims are actually combatants. In this work, Paul Preston tried to screen history from propaganda. But then he reminded us that it was war, primitive and unremitting, and that both sides, and even many innocent people around them, died of atrophic death.
The Spanish massacre is not easy to read. The author's forensic analysis of detailed cases has indeed become repeated. But the text repeats, because the real horror of the conflict, waste and stupidity begin to ease sharply. Sadly commanders and politicians have done dirty work for them by asking others to repeatedly defend their partial execution, which shows how self-obsessed leaders do it.
Then, finally, we have the right to ask: Who won? The history mentioned by Paul Preston in his book The Spanish Holocaust can provide clear answers and numerous uncertainties. However, the only person with relevant answers to this question is the victim of the conflict, so maybe we should spend some time to express their opinions.
Orignal From: Paul Preston's Spanish Massacre
No comments:
Post a Comment